Wednesday, January 28, 2015

Featherweight or Tumble Recovery?












There are a few small "Featherweight" / Tumble" models out there.
Above is the Quark and Mini Mosquito from Estes.
An early featherweight rocket kit was the Estes Streak introduced in the early 1960s.
The 13mm Mini Brute Mosquito was introduced in 1972 and had featherweight recovery.
The Estes Quark was introduced in 1997.

The 1971 Estes catalog yellow pages describes Featherweight Recovery as:
"The model is designed for extra light weight (under 1/4 oz.) and has a blunt nose. When the engine is ejected from the rocket, the model is so light compared to it's size that it lands safely.
The lightweight, aerodynamically unstable spent engine casing tumbles back separately."

What used to be described as "Featherweight Recovery" is now "Tumble Recovery".
Problem is, they don't really tumble.

Here's some of my favorite review quotes about the "featherweight" recovery of the Quark from RocketReviews.com:

"I heard it stab into the ground right next to second base."
"Dangerous rocket, flew 100+ altitude and nosed into ground twice."
"Became a 5" long lawn dart and buried itself in the soft dirt and suffered no damage."
"It doesn't tumble and will bury itself in soft ground. If it weren't for the white fins we may not have found it in the short grass." 
"The Quark had lawn darted under power into the soft turf. We laughed and decided it was a better rocket to display than fly."
"Considering the lawn dart like recovery I would guess that getting hit in the head with the pointy end off the Quark would feel like getting whacked with a golf ball. It's quite a thrill to hear the stereo "THUNK THUNK" of the Quark and it's engine landing on either side of you. Wear a hat!"
"And like others say it does not tumble, it embeds. I saw it lift off....silent..then THUNK and it landed next to me. Wear a helmet when launching :-)"
"It even LOOKS like a lawn dart. Form follows function, I guess."

The Quark doesn't have a blunt nose cone. Not a good design feature for a feather weight lawn dart!
My Estes Mini Mosquito doesn't tumble down. It also noses in after the ejection charge goes off.
Reviews of the Estes 220 Swift  - CLICK HEREsay it also nose dives in.

One of the few featherweight kits that didn't nose in was the Centuri Lil' Herc. It ejected it's engine and actually tumbled down!

You can't see it in the catalog picture but there were small washers glued onto the ends of the trailing fins. Sort of like the Estes Scout, it was stable going up and unstable coming down.

5 comments:

  1. Tumble? The 'Lil Herc? Maybe in the original version, but with the Semroc version flying with modern Estes power there's no way to tell on a small field. The ejection charge sent mine from the center of B6-4 Field over to the tennis courts on the other side of the trees about 100 yards away. I tried to convert it to mini engine power, but it wasn't stable. Like the Quark mentioned above, the Herc now resides as a shelf queen only.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Wallyum,
      I had the original Centuri :Lil Herc and it did tumble in. I didn't get the Semroc version. I probably only launched it with 1/2A engines.
      It did (at least mine did) tumble in.

      Delete
  2. The other problem is that motor casing falling out of the sky. If it doesn't hit you on the head it has a good chance of being lost. On a farm field where animals or farm machines could eat it, that's not so good.

    I converted my Mosquito to nose blow. It involves putting a tape thrust ring on the motor as well as friction fitting it and lariat looping the Kevlar shock cord — a lot more prep for such a little rocket. The one time I flew it I lost sight of it as it zipped off the pad and didn't see it again until just before it hit the ground. But at least it didn't lawn dart, or head dart...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Rich,
      I've had ejected casing hit the ground with a "thud" before. I usually find them and pick them up.
      Nose blow recovery is a smart option with these. You've got a better chance to see them after ejection.

      Delete
  3. I used a Quark to bodge together "Der Kinder Max". It always lawndarts...

    ReplyDelete